Skip to content
Insights6 min read

Who is a leader and what is leadership?

After the leadership-training hype faded, the real question remains: what do leaders actually do? Four functions, and what a century of theory says about who becomes one.

A few years ago leadership training was so fashionable that even a cleaning manager was promised a path to becoming a leader. The hype has passed, which makes it the right time to ask whether organisations really need leaders in the quantities the courses produced.

What leadership is

Roughly 80% of employees are not engaged at work. Leadership is the process by which one person influences a group toward a common goal — and a leader differs from other members by fulfilling four basic needs of the group:

  • Organising for results — the knowledge, skills, behaviour models and character traits that turn a crowd into a working team.
  • Translating the vision — showing and explaining the strategy, the direction, and how world events affect the plan. This demands developed cognitive and communication skills.
  • Gathering the team — people fear rejection and exclusion; a leader cultivates belonging and acceptance.
  • Providing safety — empathy, humanity and care for the “inner child” of employees, especially during change.

A manager is appointed from above; a leader is appointed from below, by followers. Mahatma Gandhi held no formal position yet represented India in negotiations with the British. The reverse also happens: a person is appointed head of department and the team never accepts them — tasks get done for salary and bonus, but nobody follows. The test: if the leader leaves and starts something new, do people follow?

What a century of theory says

The trait theory held that leaders possess a fixed set of qualities. Twentieth-century research dismantled it: leaders are extroverts and introverts, calm and emotionally unstable, and the list of “leader traits” in the literature has grown past a hundred — nobody has them all. A twin study put the genetic influence on outcomes at only ~24%: identical twins separated at birth chose the same cars and food, yet built completely different careers. If you develop leadership in yourself, compare yourself with yesterday's you.

Contextual theory treats leadership as the match between personality and situation: the conductor who leads an orchestra brilliantly may lose all standing in a different context, then lead again when the context restores the need. Change the environment and a different person becomes the leader.

Situational theory judges leaders not by traits or biography but by behaviour per situation. Daniel Goleman's six styles — directive (“do as I said”), benchmark (“do as I do”), visionary (“come with me”), affiliative (“people first”), democratic (“what do you think?”) and coaching (“try and learn”) — are switched between as the moment requires.

Transactional theory frames leadership as exchange: the leader meets needs for recognition, security and respect; the group returns time, skills, effort and trust.

Transformational theory adds upward influence: the leader motivates, inspires and intellectually stimulates, changing followers' values and long-term goals — and ends up changing the organisational structure and culture too.

The psychodynamic approach starts from human irrationality: people choose leaders on unconscious needs for a protector, which is also why “toxic leadership” attracts followers worth studying.

Identity theory sees leadership development as an evolution of self-awareness: a leader is someone who sees themselves as one.

Original editorial content produced for this platform. Career data — team sizes, office hubs, review scores and hiring channels — is compiled from public employer-review sources.